Why good first issues matter
A good first issue is a small, clearly described task that a new contributor can finish without knowing the whole codebase. It is one of the most practical ways to turn a visitor into someone who has already helped your project.
Newcomers tend to stop when they cannot tell where to begin. Maintainers tend to stop when every incoming pull request needs heavy rework. Good first issues address both problems by making the starting point obvious and the expected result small.
Label issues so beginners can find them
GitHub includes default labels named “good first issue” and “help wanted”. People who filter issues by label will find yours there. Open your repository’s labels page to check what exists, because the defaults can be edited or removed.
- Apply the label only to tasks that are truly small and self-contained.
- Remove the label when a task is claimed, finished or no longer suitable.
- Use “help wanted” for bigger tasks that still need outside help.
- Keep the list of open beginner issues to a size you can review regularly, rather than a pile you cannot answer.
Filters work only when labels stay accurate. A stale label sends beginners to work that no longer needs them, and they remember that.
A regular tidy-up helps. Close issues that were finished elsewhere, relabel any task that grew too big, and add a fresh beginner issue or two from the backlog so the list stays alive.
Write issues a stranger can act on
A beginner issue should answer four questions before the reader has to ask them: what is wrong or missing, where in the code it lives, what the expected result is and how to check that the change works.
Describe the problem in plain words
State the behavior you see and the behavior you want. Avoid assuming the reader knows internal names. If a term is special to your project, link to the place where it is explained.
Point to the right place
Link the file or function involved, and say which part of the flow it belongs to. A good pointer saves a newcomer a long search, and searching is often where people give up.
Explain how to test it
Name the command that runs the tests, or the page to open to see the result. A beginner who can verify their own change feels more confident about submitting it.
Say what is out of scope
One line that names what not to change keeps a first pull request focused. It also stops a newcomer from starting a large refactor by accident.
An issue template helps too, because every new issue then asks for the same details. The GitHub documentation at docs.github.com explains how to add one to your repository.
Write a CONTRIBUTING file
A CONTRIBUTING file tells people how to help. GitHub links to it from the issue and pull request pages, so it is one of the first places a contributor looks. Keep it short and specific.
- How to set up the project locally, with the exact commands.
- How to run the tests and the linter.
- How to create a branch, name commits and open a pull request.
- What kinds of change you accept, and which ones need a discussion first.
- How you respond to pull requests, and roughly how long a review may take.
Do not promise a response time you cannot keep. “I review these on weekends” is more honest than a promise that slips. A short statement about respectful behavior, or a code of conduct, also tells contributors what to expect from every conversation.
Review kindly, and fast enough
The first pull request often decides whether a newcomer returns. Review it as if you are teaching, because in a sense you are.
- Thank the contributor for the change, even when it needs work.
- Say what to change and why, and point to the part of the contributing guide that applies.
- Suggest a specific fix rather than only naming the problem.
- Merge when the change is ready. When it is not a good fit, close it kindly and explain the reason.
Celebrate a first merge where your project can. A release note or a specific thank-you comment on the pull request tells the newcomer that the work mattered, and that feeling is often why newcomers come back. Speed matters too. A pull request that waits for weeks loses its author. If you cannot review something soon, say so in a comment so the contributor knows whether to wait or to move on.
Keep contributors coming back
One merged change is a start. Repeat contributors are what keep a project healthy, and they are usually made by small kindnesses after the first merge.
Credit people in your release notes. Name each contributor and say what they fixed. The releases and changelog guide shows how to structure that section so it reads well.
Offer the next task. When a contributor’s change is merged, point them to a related issue or a slightly larger one. Most people who enjoyed the first task want a second.
Be clear about roles. If you want a regular helper to triage issues, say what that involves and what you can offer in return.
Help people find the project
Good first issues only help if people discover the project. The topics and discoverability guide explains the description, topics and social preview fields that bring people to a repository in the first place. Once a visitor arrives, a clear README and a visible contributing path do the rest.
If you want to keep a short list of beginner issues in your README, link to the label filter rather than copying the list. The link stays current without manual edits. The GitHub badge generator can add a few status badges at the top of the README if you want them.
For the wider plan, read the guide to getting GitHub stars, which covers the README, releases and contributor path together.
Where a push can help
Growing a project usually takes steady attention from maintainers and users. A clear README, good releases and visible contributions do most of the work. GitHub stars from Reachism can give a new repository an early push while the contributor path is still being built. Other options, including GitHub followers and GitHub forks, are listed on the GitHub hub. Treat any push as a bridge to real contributors, not as a replacement for them.
Frequently asked questions
How many good first issues should I keep open?
Enough that you can keep them accurate and review the pull requests they bring in. A few well-written issues are more useful than a long list nobody has checked.
Should I label an issue I am not willing to review?
No. A beginner label promises a small task that is worth a newcomer’s time. If you cannot review a contribution for it, leave the label off, or ask a trusted contributor to triage the list.
What if a newcomer never finishes?
That is normal. Comment with what would help, offer to pair on the next step, and unassign the issue after a reasonable wait so someone else can try it.
Does a small project need a CONTRIBUTING file?
It helps even for small projects, because it answers the same questions every newcomer asks. Keep it to one page and update it when the setup changes.